Horwitz Wins Defamation Suit on Behalf of Restaurateur (Again)
In another resounding win, celebrated Nashville restaurateur Randy Rayburn has again beaten back a multi-million dollar defamation and false light lawsuit filed against him by Thomas Nathan Loftis, Sr., the former director of Nashville State’s culinary program. In a unanimous ruling, the Tennessee Court of Appeals affirmed the outright dismissal of Mr. Loftis’s claims on the basis that Loftis had advanced a “far-fetched and not a reasonable interpretation” of the statements that he had sued over, and that “the statements in the newspaper article are not defamatory as a matter of law.” The Court of Appeals also ordered Mr. Loftis to pay for the costs of the lawsuit, and it further ordered the Trial Court to determine whether Loftis must pay Mr. Rayburn’s legal fees.
Given the serious threat that the case posed to the viability of newsgathering in Tennessee, the lawsuit attracted national attention from First Amendment organizations like The First Amendment Center’s Newseum Institute and TechDirt. The Court of Appeals’ decision constitutes a total victory and complete vindication for Mr. Rayburn, who has maintained that the lawsuit was frivolous from the beginning. “We’re thrilled about this resounding win, which fully vindicates Mr. Rayburn and the First Amendment yet again,” said Daniel Horwitz, Mr. Rayburn’s attorney. “Filing a lawsuit this frivolous was a very poor decision, and unfortunately for Mr. Loftis, it is about to become an expensive one as well.”
Daniel Horwitz is a First Amendment and speech defense lawyer based in Nashville, Tennessee. Selected case documents and media reports about the case are available below. If you would like to purchase a consultation from Horwitz, you can do so using the following form:
Selected Case Documents:
–Plaintiff’s First Amended Complaint
–Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss First Amended Complaint
–Plaintiff’s Response to Motion to Dismiss (1)/Plaintiff’s Response to Motion to Dismiss (2)
–Defendant’s Reply to Plaintiff’s Response
–Transcript of Hearing on Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss
–*Order Dismissing Plaintiff’s Complaint With Prejudice
–Brief of Plaintiff-Appellant Thomas Nathan Loftis, Sr.
–Brief of Defendant-Appellee and Cross-Appellant Randy Rayburn
Selected Media Coverage:
-The Tennessean: Defamation lawsuit against restaurateur Randy Rayburn dismissed — again
-TechDirt: Judge Dumps Stupid Libel Suit Featuring A Man Suing A Third Party For Things A Journalist Said
-Nashville Business Journal: Nashville restaurateur Randy Rayburn faces $1.5 million lawsuit
-TechDirt: Former University Official Files Libel Lawsuit Against His Replacement For Things A Journalist Said
-Nashville Business Journal: Judge dismisses $1.5M suit against well-known restaurateur
-First Amendment Center’s Newseum Institute: Unusual Defamation Suit Targets Source of Story
Comments
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Be the first to comment.